Holiday Shopping, Hidden Threats: How OSINT Is Combating Organized Retail Crime

Date Posted: November 12th, 2025

As the holiday shopping season approaches, so does a less visible trend: the surge in organized retail crime (ORC). Retailers across the United States brace for increased theft during this period — not merely from opportunistic shoplifters, but from well-coordinated criminal enterprises that exploit both physical and digital retail ecosystems.

According to the Retail Industry Leaders Association (RILA), organized retail theft has ballooned into a $68 billion annual problem. The National Retail Federation (NRF) estimates total “shrink” (losses from theft, fraud, and inventory mismanagement) nears $100 billion annually. These figures represent more than lost merchandise; they ripple through the economy in higher prices, lower wages, and increased risks to store employees and consumers.

The holiday shopping rush intensifies the issue. Longer hours, crowded stores, and temporary staff create conditions ripe for exploitation. November through January sees the highest volumes of theft, as professional theft rings blend into busy retail environments. Seasonal patterns are also visible online, where resale of stolen goods spikes on e-commerce platforms during gift-giving months.

Beyond Shoplifting: The Criminal Network Behind ORC

Contrary to public perception, ORC isn’t “just shoplifting.” It’s a structured, profit-driven enterprise that mimics legitimate supply chains. Sophisticated groups known as organized theft groups (OTGs) coordinate operations across states, employing “boosters” to steal, “fencers” to resell, and money launderers to disguise proceeds through shell companies, cryptocurrencies, and online marketplaces.

Federal investigations have tied some ORC proceeds to broader criminal activity, including human trafficking, narcotics trade, and terrorism financing. Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) describes the phenomenon as a transnational criminal enterprise that demands a coordinated law enforcement response.

Legislative attention has followed. The INFORM Consumers Act (2023) now requires online marketplaces to verify high-volume sellers, while the Combating Organized Retail Crime Act, currently under consideration, would give federal authorities expanded powers to prosecute multi-state operations. More than 30 U.S. states have already codified ORC as a felony-level offense.

The Financial Engine Behind the Crime

What begins as a stolen product often ends as a money laundering scheme. Financial institutions have identified ORC-linked deposits flowing through small business accounts, peer-to-peer apps, and even legitimate e-commerce platforms. Shell corporations and trade-based laundering methods make detection difficult, blending illicit proceeds with legitimate transactions.

The HSI–ACAMS ORC guide emphasizes the importance of collaboration between retailers, law enforcement, and the financial sector. Financial institutions are increasingly filing Suspicious Activity Reports (SARs) referencing ORC activity, yet these measures remain reactive. To stop these operations before profits are laundered, visibility into the digital footprint of retail crime is essential.

The OSINT Advantage: Turning PAI into Actionable Intelligence

This is where Open-Source Intelligence (OSINT) has become transformative. OSINT involves collecting and analyzing publicly available data, from social media posts to marketplace listings and dark web forums, to generate actionable intelligence.

• Detect online resale networks advertising stolen goods across multiple platforms
• Identify alias clusters and digital footprints linking boosters, resellers, and shell entities
• Correlate online listings with theft reports, shipping data, or known store incidents
• Track emerging trends in product targeting, regional theft patterns, and fraudulent refund activity
• Use network analysis to identify connections and associations among organized threat groups

Indicators such as items “new with tags,” listings with product photos taken in vehicles or warehouses, and inconsistent seller profiles often point to illicit resale. These digital breadcrumbs form the foundation for identifying organized theft groups long before prosecution.

Empowering Investigations with Tangles

At Penlink, we’ve seen firsthand how OSINT can reshape investigative outcomes. Our Tangles platform was designed to operationalize this intelligence, integrating surface, deep, and dark web data into a unified investigative environment.

With Tangles, analysts can visualize networks of digital actors, track stolen merchandise as it moves through resale markets, and share evidentiary-grade intelligence packages directly with law enforcement or financial partners. The platform’s automated entity resolution and alerting features enable rapid, cross-jurisdictional response to evolving threats.

By transforming fragmented online activity into coherent investigative intelligence, Tangles supports a whole-of-ecosystem approach, connecting retailers, law enforcement, and financial compliance teams in real time.

Next Steps

Organized Retail Crime is not a seasonal inconvenience; it’s a systemic threat that intersects with commerce, community safety, and financial integrity. As the holiday season amplifies both consumer activity and criminal opportunity, collaboration and intelligence-led action are more critical than ever.

Retailers and public agencies alike must integrate OSINT methodologies to anticipate, rather than merely react to, retail crime. Platforms like Tangles provide the visibility and speed necessary to dismantle these networks, protect assets, and safeguard communities year-round.

Schedule a demo with our experts.